Mind if I get something off my chest? No? Thanks. You’re such a good listener.
Cinemas across the country have recently begun showing the trailer for “United 93”, a new film which tells the story, in real time, of the ill-fated airliner and the souls aboard it.
Today, as I looked at the local newspaper’s web site, I was shocked to note that the trailer itself is front-page news. Apparently, moviegoers object to being shown things that are unpleasant, even (in fact, especially) when they reflect real events. A lot of people–people who probably didn’t bat an eye at the trailer to “Silence of the Lambs”–are calling the trailer “too disturbing.”
Some further research uncovered that a New York cinema with which I’m somewhat familiar (the Loews Lincoln Square 12) has even pulled the trailer after receiving numerous complaints.
I am somewhat incensed by this, and I’ll tell you why. We live in a world where the entertainment and news media seem to be tripping over each other in a fierce competition to determine who can disgust us the most. Movies and television get more explicit and ratings more permissive with each passing year, it seems. That’s not necessarily bad, but the exploitation of it can be. The media give us what the ratings tell them we want. If traffic engineers followed audience share, they’d design roads to intentionally cause accidents. If there weren’t a demand, traffic wouldn’t back up for miles as other motorists slow down to gawk at the carnage.
We, as a population, have insisted on being provided with more explicit, more repulsive, more disturbing images and situations. With our movie-going dollars and our cable fees and our video rental money, we have screamed, “DISGUST US!”
This trailer does disgust us. It was meant to. It should, because it opens the door to a story of human lives and real people that were wiped out in one violent, catastrophic moment. The trailer is distasteful because the events are distasteful. It is a powerful reminder of what was and is no more, and of why and how that came to be.
I would like to speak openly, for a moment, only to those who have complained about this trailer, voiced objections to its display, or called for its removal from theaters. If you aren’t interested in what this trailer has to say or what it shows you, please feel free to stick your head in the sand and refuse to watch it. If you’ve already seen it and are feeling out of sorts, good. You should be. However, I will thank you to please stop whining, causing trouble, and trying to appoint yourselves as censors and protectors of the general public. By all indications, this is a faithful and accurate retelling of the events of September 11, 2001. It is a story which needs to be told, and which will be told. We lost a lot of good people that day. Some of us would like to remember those people, to honor them and the sacrifice they made. Your griping cheapens that. Shut up.
Thanks. I feel better now.
Permalink
Well said that man.
Permalink
This world is full of terrible things. I can’t see the point of making movies about them.
ANY death is terrible and tragic.
I think I’ll keep my head in the sand
Permalink
You are absolutely right.
I shan’t see it. fiction or fact it’s not my sort of movie.
ttfn
Jane
Permalink
Although maybe it’s time more people objected to the trivialisation of obscenity and porn and
violence
Permalink
Yeah, interesting. I’d rather see a film about a real terrible thing than a made-up-especially-for-me terrible thing.
As long as the writers/director didn’t stick in a love interest just for hollywood reasons and have done their absolute best to recreate events as they actually occurred, this could be an excellent, if disturbing piece of work. As you say, a memorial of sorts.
Permalink
I guess these are the same people who demanded that the photo of the Falling Man should never again be shown, even though it’s an iconic photo epitomising the horror of that day, just as the naked Vietnamese girl running sums up the horror of _that_ time. There have always been films made based on real events; Raid on Entebbe, Saving Private Ryan, even The Dambusters. Why should September 11th be any different?
Permalink
/\ That was me, JG, by the way. I haven’t sussed this logging in and out bit.
Permalink
I heartily agree, Scott.
Permalink
Here here!
Would they object if it hadn’t happened on America soil?